Student Data Sharing: Is this "Big Brother Watching"? | A Blog for Principals and Teachers – School Matters

 
 

Student Data Sharing: Is this “Big Brother Watching”?

 
 

 

 

Depositphotos 24541561 s 300x199 Student Data Sharing: Is this Big Brother Watching?Readers be forewarned; I am about to age myself. When I was in school, George Orwell’s “1984” was required reading. We couldn’t imagine then that much of what the book presented would be experienced in our lifetime. “Big Brother is watching” is a common euphemism in English vernacular. With today’s search engine targeted advertising, satellite cell phone use and cloud storage, we know that little of what we do, say or write is private. In fact, it is accepted behavior to put on public forums like Facebook and other social media outlets what would have been considered private information only a decade ago. The question is often asked, “Is anything sacred anymore?”

 

Therefore, it came as a shock to many that inBloom, a $100 million education technology start-up, shut down after only 15 months of operation. Funded by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation along with the Carnegie Corporation of New York, its goal was to help personalize learning by funneling student data to software dashboards where teachers could track individual students and, with the right software, customize lessons in real time. It planned to collect and integrate student attendance, assessment, disciplinary and other records from different school-district databases, put the information in cloud storage and release it to authorized web services and apps that could help teachers track each student’s progress. Districts could effortlessly share student records with developers seeking to create educational tools for schools. It was considered a potentially revolutionary way to educate students.

 

However, opposition quickly began to build when it was understood that school districts were unequipped to manage the information being given to vendors. These included personal health and behavioral issues as well as learning challenges in very specific terms i.e. tardy, autistic, pregnant, victim of abuse, etc.

 

It is not completely new that delicate student data is shared with 3rd party vendors. For instance, outsourced bus companies have been provided with information about student physical disabilities for decades. But, to many, this information was reasonable to provide proper service. Whereas, giving overly private information to vendors whose main goal, let’s face it, is to make a profit selling learning products, apps, curriculum materials, and video games has many worried about present day misuse along with possible future damage to students. For instance, would a possible employer check the student’s history and find out something about the person from 1st grade which would prevent him from being hired as an adult?

 

Part of the problem with inBloom was that districts signed contracts with vendors without understanding the fine print. They noted that administrators had no policies in place to govern who could see the information, how long it would be kept or whether it would be shared with colleges to which students applied. All this indicated that schools were not properly prepared for the backlash which swiftly came.

 

There are other data sharing options already on the market which are working to improve the sharing of information between schools and vendors in a secure way to truly benefit students. “Clever” is one such system. It serves as a “data bridge” automatically creating and updating student accounts by securely sharing classroom roster information between schools and approved vendors. Four years ago, Clever was used by two schools. Only through word-of-mouth and with the help of substantial outside investment, Clever now connects 20,000 schools with 100 software vendors.

 

No doubt, the use of personally tailored technology for individual students is the wave of the future. Yet, perhaps the future has not arrived. Already, prekindergarten-12th grade education technology software is an $8 billion business! But, where does “helping” students begin and sharing private information cross the line?


 Share
Share and Enjoy:
  • twitter Student Data Sharing: Is this Big Brother Watching?
  • linkedin Student Data Sharing: Is this Big Brother Watching?
  • facebook Student Data Sharing: Is this Big Brother Watching?
  • googlebookmark Student Data Sharing: Is this Big Brother Watching?
 

No comments

Be the first one to leave a comment.

Post a Comment


 

Educators Calendar Events

Featured Posts

Creativity in the Classroom: Bring the Arts Back!

Most teachers and parents instinctively know that children need various modes of expression to fully develop into thriving, well-rounded adults with good self-esteem...

 
Better Ways to Use Classroom Space

Better Ways to Use Classroom Space

Most of us do not have control over which classroom we are assigned. However, we can all find ways to make the best use of the space we have. As discussed in my...

 
Flipping-Out On the Flipped Classroom

Flipping-Out On the Flipped Classroom

With this technologically savvy generation wanting to capture everything on their iPhone (“Honey, I have a great clip of the baby coming out to post on youtube...

 
With Technology in the Classroom,  The Teacher is No Longer Center Stage – Part II

With Technology in the Classroom, The Teacher is No Longer Center Stage – Part II

Last week we explored some of the positive aspects of technology in the classroom. When used correctly, technology encourages students to be active learners, inspire...

 
With Technology in the Classroom, the Teacher is No Longer Center Stage

With Technology in the Classroom, the Teacher is No Longer Center Stage

Most people believe that technology use in the classroom is a must to assure that our students have the skills and creative fortitude to function in this fast paced,...

 
Mixed Gender Behaviors in the Classroom

Mixed Gender Behaviors in the Classroom

Following two blogs I posted which generally showed that studies have found that gearing education towards gender differences leads to more successful learning,...

 
Compassionate Schools

Compassionate Schools

After my child had struggled through several mainstream schools, I decided to look into an alternative place known for its open-ended policies as well as its educational...

 
Are Extracurricular Activities Really Extra?

Are Extracurricular Activities Really Extra?

Growing up, I was one of those kids who belonged to a variety of groups. I was a cheerleader, vice-president of my class, thespian, honors student, Sunday school...

 
Is Social Media in the Classroom a Necessity or Distraction?

Is Social Media in the Classroom a Necessity or Distraction?

I recently had a telling experience while sitting at a friend’s dinner table. The mother asked her son how his class was today. He answered, “It got deleted”....

 
Video: The Myths of Chartering

Video: The Myths of Chartering

Guest Post by Ember Reichgott Junge   What a fun interview with Bob Bowdon of Choice Media TV, in New York City! We talked chartering and education issues from...