To Lead or not to Lead? School Leadership and Management | A Blog for Principals and Teachers – School Matters

 
 

To Lead or not to Lead? School Leadership and Management

 
 

 

 

iStock 000003390204XSmall 150x150 To Lead or not to Lead? School Leadership and ManagementPrincipals are busy people. It is no secret that all principals are required to wear a variety of ‘hats’, assuming the role of manager, social worker, leader, fund raiser, to name just a few. In many instances it is the ability of principals to juggle these ‘hats’ that determines their professional success or failure.

In an interesting activity that I have conducted with school principals, I have asked them to list all the possible roles they play. Each principal was given a page of colored stickers and asked to rate the importance of the roles, with the most important roles marked in red, second marked in blue and third marked in green. On each of the four different occasions the activity has been run, the results have been strikingly similar. The role of leader was washed in a sea of red, easily outdistancing any other role as the primary job description of a school principal.

However, when asked to quantify the time they dedicated to each role, the story was very different. In general, principals felt that they spent precious little time actually engaging in the role of leader, and instead focused almost all their time and energy trying to manage their school buildings, staff issues and the ever-present student crisis.

A paper published by Richard Elmore, professor at the Harvard Graduate School of Education, entitled Building a New Structure for School Leadership, finds the fault in prevalent institutional structures and the role of administrators found in those structures. Describing the current public school structure Elmore writes:

the “technical core” of education—detailed decisions about what should be taught at any given time, how it should be taught, what students should be expected to learn at any given time, how they should be grouped within classrooms for purposes of instruction, what they should be required to do to demonstrate their knowledge, and, perhaps most importantly, how their learning should be evaluated—resides in individual classrooms, not in the organizations that surround them.

Elmore feels that once administration is effectively banished from the classrooms, the only role left for the administrative superstructure of the organization —principals, board members, and administrators—is to “buffer” the weak technical core of teaching from outside inspection, interference, or disruption. Compared to the role of teachers he explains that the role of the principal consists of:

creating structures and procedures around the technical core of teaching that, at the same time, (1) protect teachers from outside intrusions in their highly uncertain and murky work, and (2) create the appearance of rational management of the technical core, so as to allay the uncertainties of the public about the actual quality or legitimacy of what is happening in the technical core…Teachers, working in isolated classrooms, under highly uncertain conditions, manage the technical core. This division of labor has been amazingly constant over the past century.

But the question that must be asked is, in effect, which came first the proverbial chicken or the egg? Were principals pushed out of the classroom or did they contribute to their banishment by forsaking their leadership role? Did teachers reject administrative leadership or simply move in to fill a leadership void? Before bemoaning the current state of school structure, principals must be able to answer the above question and be both ready and able to assume the mantle of the leadership they seek.

Share and Enjoy:
  • twitter To Lead or not to Lead? School Leadership and Management
  • linkedin To Lead or not to Lead? School Leadership and Management
  • facebook To Lead or not to Lead? School Leadership and Management
  • googlebookmark To Lead or not to Lead? School Leadership and Management
 

2 Comments

  1. Ken Timpe says:

    Karmi,

    Here’s my take on leadership vs. management in school, business, or government.

    Leadership begins with Mission, Vision, and Values. What we do, where we’re going, and what we believe in.

    Management deals with Structure, Process, and Culture.

    The mission dictates the structure…The vision drives the process…The values define the culture.

    Let the Principal lead the school, and the Teacher manage the classroom.

    • Karmi says:

      I think your descriptions are for the most part right on. I would somewhat disagree with culture being a function of management, although we may be talking about totally different aspects of culture. Your last line, accurately echoes the sentiments of my article, however, I would add that there are areas in which principals must manage and teachers must lead.

Post a Comment


 

Featured Posts

Bringing the Bible Back in Public School-Part 2

Bringing the Bible Back in Public School-Part 2

Last week, we discussed the history of the concept of “separation of church and state”. We noted extremely different degrees of religious tolerance in school...

 
Bringing the Bible Back in Public Schools-Part I

Bringing the Bible Back in Public Schools-Part I

The average citizen, school superintendant or teacher knows that in the United States of America there is something referred to as the “separation of church and...

 
Rotting to the Core – Common Core Standards

Rotting to the Core – Common Core Standards

  In June 2014, I wrote Let’s Improve Reading…Again which touched upon the topic of the Common Core standards not achieving its goals of improving the math...

 
Project Solutions for 21st Century Classrooms

Project Solutions for 21st Century Classrooms

  Introducing 21rst century classrooms into our already existing school infrastructure is a challenge that school leaders including principals, assistant principals,...

 
Bringing Nature Inside – The Benefits of Biophilic Design to Schools

Bringing Nature Inside – The Benefits of Biophilic Design to Schools

   What is Biophilic Design and How Does it Benefit the Classroom?   Biophilia is humankind’s instinctive biological connection with nature. Due to...

 
The Call on Cell Phone Policies in Schools – Part 2

The Call on Cell Phone Policies in Schools – Part 2

Last week’s blog discussed the facts that 1. Mobile devices seem to be here to stay. 2. They are addictive for young and old alike. 3. They cause serious distraction...

 
Simplifying The Process of Creating a School Budget Infographic

Simplifying The Process of Creating a School Budget Infographic

                                                    Every...

 
Hardwood Stools Come to the Rescue!

Hardwood Stools Come to the Rescue!

The Ultimate in Flexible Furniture So I’m just a grandma who retired in 2012 and downsized to a one-bedroom condo. But with eight grand-kids, I knew that...

 
The Call on Cell Phone Policies in Schools –  Part I

The Call on Cell Phone Policies in Schools – Part I

We’ve all done it or experienced it. You are sharing something deeply personal with a friend when their phone rings. “Oh, sorry. I’ll just be a minute.”...

 
Teaching Current Events in a Turbulent World

Teaching Current Events in a Turbulent World

When I was a student, current events was a standard part of the yearly curriculum. Though I remember few creative uses for the day’s newspaper cutouts, it did...