Is “Teacher Transfer” the Answer? How to Improve Low-Achieving Schools | A Blog for Principals and Teachers – School Matters

 
 

Is “Teacher Transfer” the Answer? How to Improve Low-Achieving Schools

 
 

 

 

teachertransfer 300x216 Is “Teacher Transfer” the Answer? How to Improve Low Achieving SchoolsJust like in real estate, the field of education can be boiled down to three words: location, location, location. Certain districts consistently score better than others. While there are no doubt many reasons that we can point to in order to explain the disparity between different districts, one factor is indisputable: teachers. Low-achieving schools tend to have a very difficult time attracting the most qualified teachers. After all, in addition to the academic weakness of the students, sometimes other challenges confront teachers in a low-achieving district, such as drugs or violence.


Is there a way to break out of the cycle? Is there a way to attract the best teachers to the lowest achieving schools?


The journal Education Week recently reported that a program, funded by the US Department of Education, attempted to do just that. The idea was to create a system which would draw the most experienced teachers, ones who already had track records of improving student performance, to lower-achieving schools. How so? What was the secret incentive? Another life lesson from real estate: Money talks. Under a program entitled the “Talent Transfer Initiative,” teachers were offered $20,000 to move from their current schools to substandard schools. Perhaps unsurprisingly, researchers concluded that the schools that hired these teachers saw significant improvement in academic achievement. Students raised their grades by 4-10% relative to their peers.


Some researchers welcomed the results of the study and emphasized the clear implication: talented teachers can succeed in a variety of different environments. This is indeed encouraging, as low-achieving schools can be confident that their struggles need not last forever; bring in the right people, and any school can be turned around.


However, the study also raised some serious concerns. Most people agree that teachers deserve to earn a higher wage, and the idea of granting a financial incentive seems like a good one. However, the program was offered to 1,500 relevant teacher candidates – and only 81 agreed to participate. That is a measly 5%. 5% of teachers were willing to transfer even with a $20,000 incentive. Apparently, even for a profession not known for its high salaries, there are some things more important than money.


Even if we could increase the percentage of teachers willing to transfer, the resources required to make this sort of program a widespread success seem unattainable. Who will fund these pioneering teachers? Who will pay the staff of bureaucrats to arrange all of the technical details? It sounds like a logistical nightmare.


It seems to me there is a simpler, yet more fundamental, answer to the problem of under-achieving schools. Rather than bouncing around excellent but reluctant teachers from one school to the next, let’s produce more excellent teachers. Instead of investing money in wooing that small number of excellent teachers to move to different schools, let’s create larger numbers of excellent teachers so that there are plenty to go around. Whether it’s modestly increasing salaries, improving working conditions, or enhancing professional development, there is so much we can do to increase the ranks of talented young men and women who serve as educators. It’s just one more lesson from the world of real estate: invest today to earn more tomorrow.

Share and Enjoy:
  • twitter Is “Teacher Transfer” the Answer? How to Improve Low Achieving Schools
  • linkedin Is “Teacher Transfer” the Answer? How to Improve Low Achieving Schools
  • facebook Is “Teacher Transfer” the Answer? How to Improve Low Achieving Schools
  • googlebookmark Is “Teacher Transfer” the Answer? How to Improve Low Achieving Schools
 

No comments

Be the first one to leave a comment.

Post a Comment


 

Educators Calendar Events

Featured Posts

Creativity in the Classroom: Bring the Arts Back!

Most teachers and parents instinctively know that children need various modes of expression to fully develop into thriving, well-rounded adults with good self-esteem...

 
Better Ways to Use Classroom Space

Better Ways to Use Classroom Space

Most of us do not have control over which classroom we are assigned. However, we can all find ways to make the best use of the space we have. As discussed in my...

 
Flipping-Out On the Flipped Classroom

Flipping-Out On the Flipped Classroom

With this technologically savvy generation wanting to capture everything on their iPhone (“Honey, I have a great clip of the baby coming out to post on youtube...

 
With Technology in the Classroom,  The Teacher is No Longer Center Stage – Part II

With Technology in the Classroom, The Teacher is No Longer Center Stage – Part II

Last week we explored some of the positive aspects of technology in the classroom. When used correctly, technology encourages students to be active learners, inspire...

 
With Technology in the Classroom, the Teacher is No Longer Center Stage

With Technology in the Classroom, the Teacher is No Longer Center Stage

Most people believe that technology use in the classroom is a must to assure that our students have the skills and creative fortitude to function in this fast paced,...

 
Mixed Gender Behaviors in the Classroom

Mixed Gender Behaviors in the Classroom

Following two blogs I posted which generally showed that studies have found that gearing education towards gender differences leads to more successful learning,...

 
Compassionate Schools

Compassionate Schools

After my child had struggled through several mainstream schools, I decided to look into an alternative place known for its open-ended policies as well as its educational...

 
Are Extracurricular Activities Really Extra?

Are Extracurricular Activities Really Extra?

Growing up, I was one of those kids who belonged to a variety of groups. I was a cheerleader, vice-president of my class, thespian, honors student, Sunday school...

 
Is Social Media in the Classroom a Necessity or Distraction?

Is Social Media in the Classroom a Necessity or Distraction?

I recently had a telling experience while sitting at a friend’s dinner table. The mother asked her son how his class was today. He answered, “It got deleted”....

 
Video: The Myths of Chartering

Video: The Myths of Chartering

Guest Post by Ember Reichgott Junge   What a fun interview with Bob Bowdon of Choice Media TV, in New York City! We talked chartering and education issues from...